{ "reviewed_on": "2026-09-26", "source_commit": "6ecad2e70906039c5e30cd562c1e04fc1acf5a1b", "source_repository": "https://github.com/rkarthikeyan54254/pramana", "source_paths": { "release": "data/release/pramana_v1_rc_status.json", "components": "data/release/pramana_v1_component_matrix.json", "claims": "data/release/pramana_v1_claims_contract.json" }, "release": { "release_id": "pramana-1.0-rc1", "release_class": "RELEASE_CANDIDATE", "target_ga_date": "2026-09-30", "component_baseline_commit": "db714416a3c675a58036ef16c06097138e3fdee8", "rc_ready": true, "ga_tag_ready": false, "component_count": 9, "component_matrix": "data/release/pramana_v1_component_matrix.json", "claims_contract": "data/release/pramana_v1_claims_contract.json", "invariant_checks": { "twelve_tirumurai_textual_spine_component_ready": true, "periya_puranam_component_ready": true, "nayanmar_evidence_graph_component_ready": true, "andal_173_component_ready": true, "isha_18_component_ready": true, "bhagavatam_three_locus_seed_component_ready": true, "bhagavatam_full_parent_not_overclaimed": true, "mahaperiyava_3368_metadata_component_ready": true, "mahaperiyava_authority_counts_reconciled_to_policy_3329_39": true, "mahaperiyava_source_text_not_redistributed": true, "mahaperiyava_publication_approval_not_implied": true, "component_rights_are_not_widened_by_system_release": true, "blanket_independent_verification_claim_removed": true, "excluded_scope_is_explicit": true }, "publication_model": { "universal_public_text_bundle": false, "open_profile": "rights-aware verified rows only where exact source terms permit open redistribution", "research_nc_profile": "rights-aware verified rows including qualifying CC BY-NC-SA material", "metadata_only_components": [ "andal", "isha_upanishad", "mahaperiyava_deivathin_kural_v1_v7" ], "conditional_or_internal_text_components": [ "tirumurai_1_7_tevaram", "tirumurai_8", "tirumurai_9_11", "tirumurai_12_periya_puranam" ], "research_nc_seed_components": [ "bhagavatam_narasimha_seed" ] }, "non_blocking_publication_decisions": [ "Mahaperiyava Hugging Face metadata license/terms, namespace/repository name and version tag remain a separate public-publication decision and do not widen the Pramana 1.0 core system release." ], "ga_blockers": [ "GitHub Actions runner must recover and execute one clean full corpus-ci on the final release head.", "After that clean run, perform a zero-drift release check and create the final GA freeze/tag commit." ], "operational_gate": { "github_actions_runner_healthy": false, "incident_record": "data/release/pramana_v1_ci_runner_exception.json", "final_full_ci_required": true, "zero_drift_recheck_required": true } }, "components": { "version": "1.0", "release_id": "pramana-1.0-rc1", "principle": "Component inclusion in Pramana 1.0 records a defensible product/corpus capability at its declared maturity. It never widens textual authority, historical authority, witness independence, or redistribution rights.", "components": [ { "id": "tirumurai_1_7_tevaram", "display_name": "Tirumurai 1–7 / Muvar Tevaram", "role": "SOURCE_PRESERVED_TEXTUAL_SPINE_BETA", "status_source": "data/release/tevaram_v1_beta_status.json", "component_ready_for_pramana_v1": true, "scope_summary": "Project Madurai source family plus IFP/PIFI comparison; 8,240 is preserved as the source running-number convention, not a certified unique-text count.", "authority": { "text": "SOURCE_PRESERVED_EDITION_EVIDENCE", "historical": "NOT_AUTO_VERIFIED", "independent_textual_verification": "NOT_CLAIMED" }, "public_release": { "state": "CONDITIONAL_NOT_UNIFIED_TEXT_EXPORT", "open": false, "research_nc": false, "note": "Project Madurai header conditions and IFP reuse/lineage questions remain separate." } }, { "id": "tirumurai_8", "display_name": "Tirumurai 8 / Tiruvacakam + Tirukkovaiyar", "role": "SOURCE_PRESERVED_TEXTUAL_SPINE_BETA", "status_source": "data/release/tirumurai8_v1_beta_status.json", "component_ready_for_pramana_v1": true, "scope_summary": "661 Tiruvacakam source units + 400 Tirukkovaiyar source-order units with printed-number anomalies preserved.", "authority": { "text": "SOURCE_PRESERVED_EDITION_LOCUS", "historical": "NOT_AUTO_VERIFIED", "independent_textual_verification": "NOT_CLAIMED" }, "public_release": { "state": "METADATA_OR_INTERNAL_UNTIL_SEPARATE_RIGHTS_REVIEW", "open": false, "research_nc": false } }, { "id": "tirumurai_9_11", "display_name": "Tirumurai 9–11 + Twelve-Tirumurai textual-spine closure", "role": "SOURCE_PRESERVED_TEXTUAL_SPINE_BETA", "status_source": "data/release/tirumurai9_11_v1_beta_status.json", "component_ready_for_pramana_v1": true, "scope_summary": "T9 301 source units; T10 3,046 source loci with explicit 851 lacuna and edition anomalies; T11 1,419 source units.", "authority": { "text": "SOURCE_PRESERVED_EDITION_LOCUS", "historical": "NOT_AUTO_VERIFIED", "independent_textual_verification": "NOT_CLAIMED" }, "public_release": { "state": "METADATA_OR_INTERNAL_UNTIL_SEPARATE_RIGHTS_REVIEW", "open": false, "research_nc": false } }, { "id": "tirumurai_12_periya_puranam", "display_name": "Tirumurai 12 / Periya Puranam", "role": "SOURCE_PRESERVED_HAGIOGRAPHIC_TEXT_BETA", "status_source": "data/release/periya_puranam_v1_beta_status.json", "component_ready_for_pramana_v1": true, "scope_summary": "4,286 structural verse units across 13 carukkams and 68 episode/story units; printed numbering anomalies preserved.", "authority": { "text": "SOURCE_PRESERVED", "historical": "NARRATED_NOT_INDEPENDENTLY_HISTORICALLY_VERIFIED", "independent_textual_verification": "NOT_CLAIMED" }, "public_release": { "state": "CONDITIONAL_NOT_UNIFIED_TEXT_EXPORT", "open": false, "research_nc": false } }, { "id": "nayanmar_evidence_graph", "display_name": "Nayanmar–Temple–Hymn evidence graph", "role": "EVIDENCE_GRAPH_BETA", "status_source": "data/review/nayanmar_tevaram_evidence_graph_checkpoint_v1.json", "component_ready_for_pramana_v1": true, "scope_summary": "63 saints, 68 episodes and 1,763 evidence edges; mixed hagiographic, edition-metadata and explicitly seeded epigraphic authority.", "authority": { "hagiography": "NARRATED_NOT_HISTORICALLY_VERIFIED", "traditional_places": "TRADITIONAL_REFERENCE_ONLY", "tevaram_site_hymn_links": "EDITION_METADATA", "epigraphy": "INDEPENDENT_PRIMARY_EVIDENCE_WHERE_EXPLICIT" }, "public_release": { "state": "EVIDENCE_GRAPH_WITH_SOURCE_SPECIFIC_RIGHTS", "open": false, "research_nc": false } }, { "id": "andal", "display_name": "Andal / Tiruppavai + Nachiyar Tirumozhi", "role": "SOURCE_PRESERVED_VAISHNAVA_TEXT_BETA", "status_source": "data/release/andal_v1_beta_status.json", "component_ready_for_pramana_v1": true, "scope_summary": "173 pasurams: Tiruppavai 30 + Nachiyar Tirumozhi 143; 12 mandatory review cases explicitly closed for source-preserved beta.", "authority": { "text": "SOURCE_PRESERVED_EDITION_LOCUS", "historical": "NOT_AUTO_VERIFIED", "independent_textual_verification": "NOT_CLAIMED" }, "public_release": { "state": "METADATA_ONLY_READY", "open": false, "research_nc": false, "public_metadata": true, "public_text": false } }, { "id": "isha_upanishad", "display_name": "Isha Upanishad / Kanva recension", "role": "SOURCE_PRESERVED_SANSKRIT_TEXT_BETA", "status_source": "data/release/isha_upanishad_v1_beta_status.json", "component_ready_for_pramana_v1": true, "scope_summary": "18/18 mantras; 15 conservative normalized matches and 3 explicit bounded witness differences at loci 1, 13 and 14.", "authority": { "text": "SOURCE_PRESERVED_EDITION_LOCUS", "historical": "NOT_AUTO_VERIFIED", "doctrinal_interpretation": "NOT_AUTO_VERIFIED", "independent_textual_verification": "NOT_CLAIMED" }, "public_release": { "state": "METADATA_ONLY_READY", "open": false, "research_nc": false, "public_metadata": true, "public_text": false } }, { "id": "bhagavatam_narasimha_seed", "display_name": "Bhagavatam Narasimha evidence seed", "role": "SECOND_WITNESS_ALIGNED_EVIDENCE_SEED", "status_source": "data/release/bhagavatam_narasimha_seed_v1_beta_status.json", "component_ready_for_pramana_v1": true, "scope_summary": "Exactly three Bhagavata Purana 7.8 loci: 29, 45 and 49. This is not full-parent completion.", "authority": { "text": "SOURCE_ATTESTED_AND_SECOND_WITNESS_ALIGNED", "historical": "NOT_AUTO_VERIFIED", "doctrinal": "NOT_AUTO_VERIFIED", "independent_textual_verification": "NOT_CLAIMED" }, "public_release": { "state": "RESEARCH_NC_READY_AS_SEED", "open": false, "research_nc": true, "full_parent": false } }, { "id": "mahaperiyava_deivathin_kural_v1_v7", "display_name": "Mahaperiyava / Deivathin Kural V1–V7", "role": "METADATA_RETRIEVAL_AND_PRODUCT_FOUNDATION", "status_source": "data/review/mahaperiyava_hf_release_policy.json", "product_status_source": "data/review/mahaperiyava_phase19_app_readiness_checkpoint.json", "component_ready_for_pramana_v1": true, "scope_summary": "3,368 public-safe curator metadata records across Volumes 1–7; grounded retrieval/backend/product stack ready for consolidation.", "authority": { "dk_attested": 3329, "earlier_witness_supported": 39, "primary_source_verified": 0, "source_text_redistributed": false }, "public_release": { "state": "METADATA_RELEASE_CANDIDATE_PUBLICATION_NOT_APPROVED", "open": false, "research_nc": false, "publication_approval": false } } ], "excluded_from_pramana_v1_ga_scope": [ "full 4,000-pasuram Divya Prabandham hardening beyond Andal", "full 12-skandha Bhagavata Purana release hardening", "additional Upanishads beyond Isha", "Bhagavad Gita production hardening", "new major corpus families not already hardened" ] }, "claims": { "version": "1.0", "release_id": "pramana-1.0-rc1", "allowed_claims": [ "Pramana 1.0 includes a source-preserved Twelve-Tirumurai textual spine at explicitly declared beta maturity.", "Pramana 1.0 includes Andal's 173-pasuram source-preserved beta.", "Pramana 1.0 includes an 18-mantra Kanva Isha Upanishad source-preserved beta.", "Pramana 1.0 includes a three-locus Bhagavatam Narasimha evidence seed; it does not claim full Bhagavatam hardening.", "Pramana 1.0 includes a 63-saint Nayanmar evidence graph whose edge authority is source-qualified.", "Pramana 1.0 includes 3,368 Mahaperiyava/Deivathin Kural public-safe metadata records: 3,329 dk_attested and 39 earlier_witness_supported; primary_source_verified remains 0.", "A component can be ready for the Pramana 1.0 system while its source text remains unavailable for public redistribution.", "verified=true in legacy public scripture rows means the verification semantics declared by that source contract; it does not automatically mean editorially independent witnesses." ], "prohibited_claims": [ "All Pramana corpora are independently textually verified.", "All source text included in Pramana 1.0 is approved for public redistribution.", "The full 4,000-pasuram Divya Prabandham is hardened for Pramana 1.0.", "The full 12-skandha Bhagavata Purana is hardened or GA-ready.", "The Mahaperiyava metadata bundle contains Deivathin Kural source text or verbatim Mahaperiyava speech.", "All Mahaperiyava records are print checked or primary-source verified.", "Mahaperiyava Hugging Face publication is approved.", "Hagiographic narration is independently verified history merely because it is present in a source-preserved text.", "A separately hosted digital witness is independent merely because its text agrees." ], "terminology": { "source_preserved": "Text is preserved and addressable in the declared edition/source lane; this does not imply historical truth or independent textual verification.", "second_witness_aligned": "A second presentation/witness was compared substantively under an explicit contract; independence must be separately established.", "metadata_only": "Public-safe metadata may be exported while underlying source text remains restricted or separately gated.", "system_ga": "Pramana product/repository release over components at declared maturity; it is not a blanket public-text publication license." } } }